Northwich 21 – 10 New Brighton
Team: 1. Lee McCourt, 2. Lewis Mullen, 3. John Brotherton, 4. Paul Campbell, 5. Ryan Stead, 6. Danny Jones, 7. Wayne Clayton, 8. Kati Tu’ipulotu, 9. Alan Hesketh, 10. Steve Dean, 11. Josh Bates, 12, Loa Tupou, 13, Chris Dale, 14. Joe Bowmer, 15. Rick Hopkin.
Replacements: 16. Dan Stafford, 17. Phillip Buckley, 18. Ali Child.
Poor Performanc by the Blues
A close inspection of all their previous results, particularly the corresponding fixture at Hartsfield earlier in the season, clearly showed that Northwich, despite their lowly league position, are a team that deserve respect, especially on their own patch, and the Blues failed to give them sufficient respect. Put in the added ingredient of the home team and particularly their fans, intent on winding up their past players in the visiting team, a warm welcome was assured for the much changed New Brighton outfit. The visitors kicked off into the stiff breeze and a bright low sun, hoping that they could keep well in contention until the elements were in their favour. Unfortunately a penalty after 3 minutes and a try under the posts 4 minutes later after some weak tackling in the centre of the field was anything but the start required, leaving them 10 – 0 down after just 8 minutes.
Some good attacking play, with Loa and Kati to the fore, allowed Dean to kick a penalty from close in to reduce the deficit to 10 – 3 after 13 minutes. Despite their poor start, the Blues now produced their best rugby and went close on several occasions. Some bad handling occasionally left them down and Northwich were quick to use the wind effectively to turn defence into attack and only some poor handling themselves saved the New Brighton line on several occasions. Dale was particularly targeted and had suffered several heavy tackles. However, being the effervescent character that he is, he certainly gave as good as he got. One such heavy tackle earned the referee’s disapproval and a straightforward 3 points for Northwich took them to 13 – 3 after 30 minutes. Another good drive by the home pack took them deep into the Blues territory but neat defensive work by the Brighton half-backs cleared the situation. The visitors were relieved to reach half time with just a 10 point deficit. Despite a very indifferent start, they had shown plenty of resolve, despite some problems in the set pieces, for the travelling faithful to feel optimistic about their chances with the wind at their backs.
Half Time Northwich 13 – 3 New Brighton
This optimism was to be dashed when New Brighton failed to win sufficient quality ball in the early exchanges to enable them to use the wind to gain territorial advantage. Several basic errors such as kicking into touch on the full and the compounding problems in the scrum gave the home side every encouragement to hassle the Blues sufficiently for their flaky composure to waver under pressure. At one disintegrating scrum, New Brighton were penalised for standing up and the referee misinterpreted Beefy’s explanation that he was effing boring to march them 10 yards upfield. Sufficiently close for stand-off Hayes to land a good goal, admittedly with a lull in the wind, giving the home side a lead of 16 – 3 after 48 minutes.
There was a definite improvement after this but the visiting side were still prone to basic mistakes, errors that should have been left on the practice ground. A super try by the visitors lifted the spirit considerably. A scrum on the home 10m line saw Kati picking up and laying off to his scrum half who gave a lovely flat pass to Hopkin, steaming up from full back and straight through the narrowest of gaps in the home defence to score under the posts for Dean to convert, reducing the deficit to a manageable 16 – 10 after 60 minutes.
A fortuitous try for Northwich and a New Brighton red card ended the Blues resistance. With 15 minutes to go, the home backs, attacking from the Blues 10-yard line, sent a pass to ground only for a lucky bounce and a hint of a knock enabling left winger Campbell to hack on and win the race to the touchdown. The failed conversion still left the Blues with a mountain to climb. The substitution of Clayton by Child, who went on the wing, meant Bates reverting to his natural position of flanker (for all of two minutes). Another crunching, but seemingly fair, tackle by Dale again incurred the referee’s disapproval and a yellow card was shown. Dale, thinking perhaps that he was playing football, let the referee know his disapproval in no uncertain terms, leaving the ref with no option, unlike his footballing colleagues, of a second yellow card and dismissal of Dale from the field of play. Northwich finished strongly, putting even more pressure on their opponents’ seven man scrum, and the Blues were relieved not to concede further points before the final whistle.
Full Time: Northwich 21 – 10 New Brighton
There is no doubt this was a disappointing result and a below par performance by a side competing for promotion in this league and still just 4 points adrift of the league leaders, despite this setback. The error count is far too high and ill-discipline is costing us dear. The gamble of playing Loa at centre produced mixed results, he was undoubtedly a handful for the opposition defence with his powerful runs but the ¾ line as a whole lacked fluency and need to work on their defensive alignment. Whilst the team clearly missed Mike Gallimore’s combative play, Alan Hesketh had an excellent game at scrum-half. His passing was generally crisp and his covering prodigious. The back row was workmanlike and some of the forward drives were very effective.
There are times when the Blues’ individual talent is clearly commensurate with a side with aspirations of promotion. However, as a team, they are too often dysfunctional, profligate with basic errors, often playing as if with strangers. Coach Steve Dorrington said “today’s performance was as insipid a display from a group of people representing New Brighton that I have seen for some time”.